1. Home
  2. Hobbies & Games
  3. Collectibles

Antiques Roadshow Oklahoma City

By Barbara Crews, About.com

5 of 9

Red Wing Monk is NOT California Pottery

Courtesy of OETA
Now for the real disappointment of the day -- let me start off by saying, it's obvious that not everyone can know everything and I would never expect an appraiser to know it all, how could they? But I do expect an appraiser to say "they don't know" when they don't. And it turns out that it wasn't even my item that was screwed up!

I was second in line with the flying saucer jar, behind someone with a blue Red Wing Monk cookie jar. The appraiser was gone, and the "monk person" said the appraiser had to go find more information on the jar, the appraiser didn't know if it was Red Wing or a Twin Winton jar. Well, you know me, I told her it was Red Wing, but that's all I said. The appraiser comes back in a bit and tells the "monk person" that the jar is California Pottery and worth $100. - $150. Hello? Now of course I had to speak up, and said (very nicely) sorry, but that is a Red Wing jar. The owner turns it over to show me the mark previously shown to the appraiser, it read Red Wing quite clearly. The appraiser said, "well I just couldn't read the mark clearly". Although I can understand someone not familiar with cookie jars not being sure of the value, the name Red Wing Pottery should be very familiar and not be thought a California pottery!

5 of 9

Explore Collectibles

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Hobbies & Games
  3. Collectibles
  4. MORE Collecting Resources
  5. Antique Roadshow
  6. Antique Roadshow Visits Oklahoma City

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.