Todd Merrill was featured on an episode of American Pickers a while back and his natural style in front of the cameras caught the eye of the producers. When they (same producers do both Picked Off and American Pickers) had the idea for this show, he was the one contacted. Todd was all in and the next step was finding another appraiser, looking for a good fit. He suggested they check out his brother Ethan Merrill, who runs the family auction business, Duane Merrill & Company in Vermont. It was a natural fit with the brothers in perfect sync in how they approach items and their appraising skills and interests.
Show host is Keith Neubert, actor, producer and former NFL player.