These jars have been found marked or advertised with a McCoy mark, they are not the REAL McCoy. These jars are copies of jars from other companies or ceramic mold jars. The makers mark them McCoy, taking advantage of the popularity of the company. The company name shown under some of the jars is the company that made the authentic jar. This list is by no means complete and in the case of a jar like the Mammy -- almost every variation of a Mammy cookie jar has been copied and marked McCoy.
Not McCoy: A - B
- Betty Boop
Benjamin Medwin/Vandor - Betty Boop Black
- Black Chef
National Silver/Pearl China - Brayton Mammy
Brayton, advertised as McCoy Brayton
Not McCoy: C - D
- Chick
American Bisque - Chef- Black
- Cinderella
- Cow Jumped Over the Moon
Robinson Ransbottom - Cow with Finial on back
Brush - Clown - Standing Striped pants
- Cow (Daisy)
Metlox - Davy Crockett Boy
Brush - Dixie Mammy
- Dog with Fireman's Hat
- Donald Duck Turnabout
- Dumbo
Leeds China
